So basically, your argument that everybody in the world is wrong about Silent Hill except for some (but not all) of the original team members, and you. Is that right?
give yourself a star.
is it so unlikely? when you are dealing with a survival horror game that actually treats its players like an adult and doesn't spoon feed you everything and has it's own way of telling a story, you are bound to get all of the morons to misunderstand it.
the only sources i need are the games themselves, and the words of men who actually wrote, directed and designed the games.
and yes, the members of silent hill who actually wrote and designed the game are right because they wrote and designed the game, so my god yes... they are right and not the music composer who never had any ambition to be the producer and was never qualified to begin with, actually does not understand silent hill as well as the men who wrote, designed and directed the games. is that so unlikely?
i actually care about silent hill. i have replayed these games multiple times and i payed attention to what characters say and how they say them. these games (the first 4 in particular) were made for adults and respect the player.
as evidence by the games that came out post 4 and the interviews by Tom Hullett, he clearly didnt have an understanding either. which is why one cannot accept any of the games post 4 as an authentic silent hill game, despite what konami would have you believe. but this is another issue.
i am not alone on this. there are others who actually understand the story of silent hill because not everyone who played them is a complete moron... especially since everything i have said can be backed up by the original 4 games, and by the words of the original team members who created it.
your arrogance made you content to settle for your fan theories that make you look like a blithering-drooling mongoloid.
what your should do is investigate.
replay the original games, and actually pay very close attention.
you care about survival horror? fucking act like it.